The Role of AI in SEO: What’s Changing in 2025?

AI isn’t new, but its impact on digital marketing has exploded in just a few short years. Media outlets started using AI-generated content for sports and weather reporting in the mid-2010s, and chatbots have leveraged machine learning for nearly just as long. But everything changed in late 2022 when ChatGPT hit the scene. AI and Machine learning was suddenly available to the masses and became a daily tool for digital marketing firms and local SEO agencies.

Today, AI is helping with everything from content creation and keyword research to analyzing search results and speeding up content optimization. But let’s be real. Just because AI can assist with blog posts or crunch SEO data doesn’t mean it can replace human expertise. You still need strategy. You still need context. You still need a pulse on what actually moves the needle in real-world marketing.

In this article, we’ll break down how AI is reshaping local SEO in 2025 — and how smart businesses are combining AI efficiency with human insight to stay visible and competitive with their SEO strategies. 

AI-Generated Content: Assistance, Not Replacement

Content optimization with relevant keywords is essential for ranking high in search engine results. However, the growing accessibility of AI-powered tools like Claude, ChatGPT, Gemini, Surfer SEO, Frase, and DeepSeek has led to a massive increase in AI-generated content. While AI tools can speed up writing and automate tasks, they often produce generic, keyword stuffed content that lacks depth and fails to gauge user intent, directly contradicting Google’s emphasis on relevant, high-quality content.

Google’s continued emphasis on E-E-A-T (Experience, Expertise, Authoritativeness, Trustworthiness) remains a key ranking factor. To perform well in search engine results, content must provide real value to users, with keywords strategically placed to match user intent rather than just search volume. While AI-generated content can help businesses appear in more searches, ranking alone isn’t enough. Users won’t stay on a website or engage if the content lacks depth and relevance.

AI does not have human creativity, industry expertise, or personal insights to make content engaging and authoritative. This is especially important in Local SEO, where understanding a community’s specific language, culture, and search behaviors is pivotal for driving local search results and attracting potential customers.

While AI is an invaluable tool for improving efficiency and automating time consuming tasks in digital marketing, human expertise is still essential for refining and personalizing content, natural keyword integration, and maintaining brand voice and consistency. 

Best practices to rank high in search results involve combining AI efficiency with human expertise. In our experience, AI is a great tool for ideation and drafting, but human editors are essential to refine and create authentic, engaging, and helpful content. A human touch ensures content aligns with effective SEO strategies tailored to your audience and goals.

AI in Search Algorithms: Google’s Evolving Approach

Before AI, users relied on short- and long-tail keywords to find relevant information. For example, a short-tail keyword like “local SEO agency” or “digital marketing services”  are broad and competitive, while a long-tail keyword such as “best local SEO agency near me for small businesses” is more specific and intent-driven. Users would manually scan multiple search results to find the most relevant answer. Now, AI powered search engines generate instant summaries before showing ads and organic search results.

Google’s Search Generative Experience (SGE) provides AI-generated responses directly in answer to the user’s query. While this improves user experience, it has reduced the visibility of organic search listings, leading to lower click-through rates for many small businesses. With fewer users clicking beyond AI-generated summaries, digital marketing firms and local SEO agencies are adapting their SEO strategies to drive organic traffic and boost search rankings. 

AI is also automating critical SEO tasks, including site audits, meta tag optimization, and schema markup. Tools like Google Search Console, Screaming Frog, and Botify are streamlining technical SEO processes, improving efficiency for businesses. However, while AI can analyze vast amounts of search data, it still requires SEO experts to interpret findings, make strategic decisions, and optimize the overall website experience.

Here’s how local SEO experts are optimizing for AI-driven search:

• Target featured snippets – Create concise, high-value content that provides direct answers and encourages users to visit the page for more details.

• Enhancing structured data – Implementing schema markup to help search engines better understand and display website content.

• Optimize metadata – Ensure titles, URLs, and meta descriptions include relevant keywords to improve visibility in search engine results.

• Create in-depth, value-driven content – Integrate unique insights, human experiences, and expertise that AI-generated content cannot replicate.

• Build brand authority and trust – Strengthen credibility to encourage repeat visits and improve customer retention.

As AI continues to evolve, businesses must focus on high-quality content, structured data, and user engagement to stay visible. While automation improves efficiency, human expertise is essential for making sense of the data, refining strategies, and ensuring content remains relevant, trustworthy, and user-focused.

AI and Keyword Research: Smarter, Not Simpler

AI SEO tools like Semrush, Ahrefs, and RankIQ have refined keyword research, making it easier to analyze search intent and competition. However, human expertise is still essential to interpret data accurately and connect insights with brand voice and customer needs.

Using high-volume keywords without understanding user intent or conducting target audience research won’t guarantee higher search engine rankings. Instead, ongoing SEO audits and continuous refinement of SEO strategies are necessary to maintain rankings, retain customers, and attract new ones.

Digital marketing firms and local SEO agencies provide a comprehensive approach that goes beyond AI generated keyword research and content creation to deliver real and measurable results. Here’s why:

• Overloading content with high volume keywords while neglecting long-tail keywords can cause businesses to miss out on high-value leads. Instead of standing out, they risk blending into an oversaturated market filled with generic content. Human insight and strategic thinking are key to effective keyword integration, ensuring content remains relevant and engaging. 

• Customer feedback reveals pain points, preferences, and market gaps that AI may not be able to identify. A successful SEO strategy requires this human insight to analyze this data and create personalized marketing strategies. 

• Unedited, AI generated content can sound awkward and robotic. Manual refinement ensures that content is clear, engaging, and optimized for both search engines and users.

The Impact of AI on Local & Voice Search

AI powered voice assistants like Siri, Alexa, and Google Assistant have changed how people search for information. Instead of singular keywords, users now phrase queries in a conversational and more natural language. This shift means businesses must optimize their content for natural language processing, focusing on user intent to improve local search engine results.

AI enhanced personalization has also affected local SEO, requiring businesses to develop an SEO strategy that delivers more hyper-localized results based on intent-driven traffic and location.

To stay competitive, local SEO agencies are adapting by:

• Optimizing for natural language search and voice queries to align with how users ask questions.

• Keeping a business’s Google Business Profile updated with localized content, including contact details, directions, reviews, and posts to attract potential customers nearby.

• Creating question-and-answer content such as FAQs to provide relevant responses for verbal search queries.

A local SEO agency offers comprehensive digital marketing services that help businesses navigate these evolving SEO strategies, helping leverage AI driven advancements to improve search engine rankings and attract high-value leads.

AI in Link Building & Digital PR

An effective SEO strategy incorporates on-page, off-page, and technical SEO to improve search engine rankings. This includes keyword research, high-quality content, meta tags, URL and title optimization, and internal and backlinks that drive traffic to your website and digital content.

AI can assist with backlink analysis by evaluating the quality and quantity of inbound links, identifying potential outreach opportunities to streamline digital PR efforts. AI tools can help research high-authority sites for link-building and automate aspects of prospecting, making it easier to connect with relevant platforms.

However, while AI enhances efficiency by handling research and data analysis, relationship building remains a human-driven process. Establishing credibility, fostering connections with industry influencers and journalists, and maintaining a strong brand image require human expertise. Genuine outreach, trust, and reputation management are beyond AI’s capabilities, making human involvement essential for long-term SEO success.

The Future of AI in SEO: What Businesses Should Do Now

As AI continues to advance, businesses must remember that AI is a tool, not a strategy. Human creativity, strategic thinking, and real-world insights remain vital for success. 

Here’s what businesses should focus on in 2025:

1. Prioritize E-E-A-T: Build trust, credibility, and brand authority by creating content that demonstrates expertise and experience.

2. Optimize for AI-powered search: Focus on conversational content, structured data, and personalized engagement to work optimally with AI driven search experiences.

3. Combine AI and human expertise: Let AI handle data and automation, but keep humans in control of the message and strategy.

Leverage AI and the Human Edge for an Effective Local SEO Strategy

AI advancements in recent years have changed how SEO is done, automating tasks like keyword research, content optimization, and technical audits. While AI improves efficiency, it still lacks human creativity, critical thinking, and the ability to connect with audiences on a deeper level. Businesses must combine AI driven efficiency with human expertise to create high-quality content, stay competitive, and keep up with evolving AI SEO trends.

Sounds overwhelming?

Partner with a local SEO agency so you can focus on running your business while experts handle your digital presence, helping you stay ahead of the competition and achieve long-term success.

We hope the tips above are helpful in improving your digital campaigns. Have more questions about partnering with an agency? Reach out to us directly.

Subscribe to Get The Latest Insights.

What makes marketing so challenging?

Trying to keep-up with the tools, technology and the limited attention span of your target market are all challenging. Get our tips on how to grow leads and revenue, delivered directly to your inbox.